Open Now Bountiful (801) 821-3149
Right Way Plumbing

Family-owned · Bountiful Local

Garbage Disposal Repair in Bountiful

Jammed, humming, or leaking, Scott diagnoses the problem and fixes it the same visit.

(801) 821-3149 Get an estimate 4.9 from 140 Google reviews
Garbage Disposal Repair in Bountiful

Request an estimate

Tell us what you need

No obligation · Responds within 1 business day

By submitting this form you agree that we may contact you about your request and share your name and email address with partner companies for email marketing. We never share your mobile number or text message consent with third parties or affiliates for marketing or promotional purposes.
★★★★★
“Scott with Right Way Plumbing is always my go to. He does exactly what he says, shows up on time and is incredibly knowledgeable. …”
Shelly R. · Google review

Garbage Disposal Repair Bountiful Homeowners Rely On

Right Way Plumbing handles garbage disposal repair in Bountiful and across Davis County, jams, failed motors, leaking mounting flanges, and full replacements when a repair no longer makes sense. Scott Rasmussen has 4.9 stars across 140 Google reviews, and one of those reviews came from a customer whose old disposal he hauled out himself so they wouldn't have to. That's the kind of visit you'll get. Call (801) 821-3149 now and Scott will tell you straight on the phone whether your unit is worth fixing.

What separates a repairable disposal from a dead one usually comes down to where the failure started. A humming motor that won't spin typically means a jammed impeller or a tripped overload button, both fixable in one visit without replacing the unit. A disposal that's completely silent after you flip the switch points to an electrical fault: a tripped breaker, a bad wall switch, or a burned-out motor. Leaks are almost always mechanical: a cracked splash guard, a loose sink flange, or worn-out gaskets at the drain connection. Utah's hard water accelerates mineral buildup inside the grinding chamber, which can corrode the impeller plate faster than you'd expect in a softer-water market. If your unit is under eight years old and failed mechanically rather than electrically, repair usually makes more financial sense than replacement. Older than ten years with a burned motor? Replacement tends to win. Every job is different, contact Right Way Plumbing for an accurate estimate.

Common Failures

Why Your Disposal Stopped Working Stopped Working

Most disposal failures fall into one of three categories, and knowing which one you have changes everything about how we fix it.

Jammed Impeller

A foreign object, a bottle cap, a cherry pit, a piece of bone, lodges between the impeller and the grinding ring. The motor hums but the plate won't rotate. Don't keep hitting the switch. You're drawing current through a stalled motor, and that burns the windings fast. We clear the jam manually using the hex socket on the underside of the unit, check the impeller for damage, and test spin before we leave.

Tripped Overload or Electrical Fault

Complete silence when you flip the switch means no power is reaching the motor. Check the red reset button on the bottom of the disposal first. If it's popped out, press it and try again. If that doesn't fix it, the fault is upstream: a tripped breaker, a failing wall switch, or a burned-out motor. We trace the circuit and find it.

Leaking Mounting Flange

Water pooling under your sink directly below the disposal almost always originates at the mounting flange where the unit connects to the sink basin. The plumber's putty seal degrades over time, especially with Utah's mineral-heavy water leaving deposits around the joint. We pull the disposal, clean the sink opening, re-seal with fresh putty, and reseat the mounting assembly properly.

Cracked Splash Guard or Worn Gaskets

Leaks at the side or bottom drain outlet point to the splash guard or the gaskets connecting the disposal to your drain line. A cracked splash guard lets water escape every time the unit runs. Gasket failure at the dishwasher inlet or drain connection is a separate but equally common cause of under-sink moisture. Both are straightforward fixes if caught before the water damages your cabinet floor.

Mineral Buildup and Corrosion

Davis County water tests consistently hard, significant calcium and magnesium content that coats the inside of your grinding chamber, the impeller, and the drain connection over time. Buildup restricts rotation, accelerates bearing wear, and can lock an impeller that would otherwise spin freely. If your disposal is grinding slowly or not draining fast enough, mineral accumulation is often the culprit before any mechanical failure shows up.

Drain Connection Clog

Sometimes the disposal runs fine but water backs up anyway. That's a drain problem, not a disposal problem, and the two are easy to confuse. We check the P-trap and the line running toward the wall before replacing any hardware. If the clog runs deeper, we can connect you to our drain cleaning service to clear the line properly.

Repair or Replace? The Honest Answer

This is the question most homeowners have before we arrive, and it's one we'll answer directly on the phone.

  1. Check the age first

    A well-made disposal has a realistic lifespan of 10 to 12 years with normal use. If yours is past that mark and the motor has failed, replacement is almost always the better call. Under eight years old with a mechanical fault? We repair it.

  2. Match the failure to the fix

    Jams, gasket leaks, and tripped overloads are all repairable without touching the motor or the housing. A burned-out motor on a mid-grade unit typically costs more to source and install than a new unit of equal quality. We won't recommend a repair that costs more than it's worth.

  3. Factor in the unit's quality

    A commercial-grade or high-horsepower disposal is worth repairing because the replacement cost is genuinely high. A builder-grade unit with a failed motor is not. We'll tell you which category yours falls into before we pick up a tool.

  4. We install units you supply

    If you've already purchased a replacement unit, InSinkErator, Moen, Waste King, whatever you chose, we install it. Bring your own hardware, and Scott handles the mounting flange connection, the drain line, the dishwasher inlet, and the electrical. No markup on your unit.

How It Works

What Happens When We Show Up

  1. Diagnose Before We Touch Anything

    Scott checks the power, the overload button, the mounting assembly, and the drain connection before recommending any repair. Five minutes of diagnosis prevents a lot of unnecessary parts. You'll know what's wrong and what it takes to fix it before any work starts.

  2. Repair or Replace: Your Call

    Once the fault is identified, we walk you through the options honestly. Repair it, replace it with a new unit, or install the one you already bought. No pressure either direction. The recommendation comes from the diagnosis, not from what's more profitable.

  3. Test, Clean, and Confirm

    After the repair or installation, we run water through the unit, check all connection points for leaks, verify the drain is flowing cleanly, and wipe down the cabinet. The job isn't finished until everything works the way it should.

Keep Your Disposal Running Longer

Honest answer: most disposals die early because of what goes into them, not because they were built poorly. Fibrous foods like celery, artichoke leaves, and onion skins wrap around the impeller shaft and strain the motor over hundreds of cycles. Grease and cooking fat solidify in the drain line just past the disposal, creating a clog that looks like a disposal failure but isn't. Starchy foods, pasta, rice, potato peels, expand in water and pack the grinding chamber. None of that is obvious until something stops working. Hard water compounds the problem. The mineral content in Bountiful's water supply leaves calcium deposits inside the grinding chamber that restrict impeller movement over time. Running cold water for 30 seconds after the disposal stops is one of the simplest things you can do: it flushes residue through the P-trap before it has a chance to harden. Grinding a handful of ice cubes once a week knocks loose mineral buildup without any cleaning products. If you notice slow draining at the kitchen sink, don't ignore it, a partial clog in the disposal drain puts strain on the motor that compounds into a real failure faster than you'd expect. Our drain and sewer service team can clear that line before it becomes a bigger issue. And if your fixture repair needs extend beyond the disposal, a worn faucet, a leaking sink strainer, we handle that in the same visit.
jammed impeller work, professional service in Bountiful, Utah

Serving Bountiful and Davis County

Right Way Plumbing is based in Bountiful and covers all of Davis County plus the northern Salt Lake valley. Scott answers the phone himself. No dispatch queue, no callback window. If you're in any of the communities below, you're in the service area.

Call (801) 821-3149

Straight from Google

What Customers Say About Scott actually check

4.9140 verified Google reviews
Best experience with a plumber we have ever had. So polite and knowledgeable, came even before he was expected. Was super fast, and even hauled out the old dishwasher and garbage disposal for us so we didn’t have to worry about doing that ourselves! Highly highly recommend and I’m saving the contact info for any future plumbing needs! We are a lifelong customer now!
Justice WorksJustice WorksOct 2026 · Google
Scott with Right Way Plumbing was absolutely fantastic! He was at my house within an hour of my initial call, which was incredibly impressive! He was extremely friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient. He quickly diagnosed the problem with our water heater and took care of everything in a timely manner. You can tell he really knows his stuff and takes pride in his work. It’s refreshing to find someone who provides such outstanding customer service. I highly recommend Scott and Right Way Plumbing!
Ty HarrisonTy HarrisonOct 2026 · Google
Scott with Right Way Plumbing is always my go to. He does exactly what he says, shows up on time and is incredibly knowledgeable. It is very clear how experienced Scott is and I have complete trust in recommending him to my clients .. both Buyers and Sellers. Scott is fair and honest and his first concern is aways to take care of his clients.
Shelly RussonShelly RussonOct 2026 · Google
Scott does fantastic plumbing work! He is fair with his pricing and honest. We have used him to check out water heaters, pipes, toilets, the works. We use him on many of the properties we manage. Great guy!
Brooklyn FitzgeraldBrooklyn FitzgeraldOct 2026 · Google
Scott and Right Way Plumbing are phenomenal. They always do a good job and have tons of experience. We run a property management company and use him on a lot of our homes. We recommend him every day of the week.
Joseph FitzgeraldJoseph FitzgeraldOct 2026 · Google
Scott was great! He worked on our tankless water heater and had it fixed in a little over an hour. Kept me informed the entire time and very reasonably priced. Definitely recommend 😊
Kim ClineKim ClineOct 2026 · Google
Scott was timely, transparent, reasonably priced, and very clean. I highly recommend Right Way Plumbing!!
Maren HansenMaren HansenOct 2026 · Google
I am so grateful for my plumber of many years, Scott Rasmussen of Right Way Plumbing! Every experience has been exceptional and at a very reasonable & fair price! He is professional, very knowledgeable, punctual, honest & respectful of my home. Scott takes the time to explain everything clearly, completes the work efficiently, with great expertise & attention to detail. The quality of his workmanship is outstanding. It's wonderful to have a trusted plumber who takes such pride in his work and genuinely cares about doing the job right. If you are looking for a plumber who is honest, skilled, very knowledgeable with exceptional troubleshooting abilities that can resolve your issues, I highly recommend & completely trust Right Way Plumbing!
Susan FrigmSusan FrigmSep 2026 · Google
Read all 140 reviews

Call Right Way Plumbing for Disposal Repair

Jammed, humming, leaking, or completely dead, Scott diagnoses the problem fast and fixes it the same visit.

Call (801) 821-3149 Call Now, We Answer 24/7

Frequently asked questions

Do you call a plumber to fix a garbage disposal?
Yes, and specifically when the problem involves the drain connection, the mounting flange, or a suspected electrical fault. Jams are sometimes manageable with a hex wrench at the unit's base, but if resetting the overload button and manually unjamming the impeller don't fix it, a licensed plumber should diagnose from there. Wiring faults and drain-line clogs behind the P-trap aren't DIY territory. Scott handles all of it in a single visit.
Are garbage disposals worth repairing?
Depends on three things: age, failure type, and the quality of the original unit. A disposal under eight years old with a mechanical failure, jammed impeller, leaking flange, worn gaskets, is almost always worth repairing. A unit over ten years old with a burned motor typically isn't, because the motor sourcing cost approaches or exceeds a new mid-grade unit. Scott will give you the honest answer on the phone before he drives out, not after he's already there.
How does Utah's hard water affect garbage disposals?
Davis County water carries significant calcium and magnesium content. Inside a disposal's grinding chamber, those minerals deposit on the impeller plate and the grinding ring over time, restricting rotation, accelerating bearing wear, and narrowing the drain opening. It's one reason disposals in this market fail earlier than their rated lifespan suggests. Running cold water for 30 seconds after each use and grinding ice cubes weekly both help slow the buildup between service visits.
What should I do before the plumber arrives for disposal repair?
Turn off the disposal at the wall switch and leave it off, don't keep cycling power through a jammed motor. Clear out the cabinet under the sink so there's working room around the P-trap and drain connection. If there's standing water in the sink, bail it out. Don't pour drain cleaner into the disposal; it won't clear a mechanical jam and it complicates the repair. That's it. Scott handles everything from there.
My disposal runs fine but water backs up in the sink, is that a disposal problem?
Usually not. A disposal that runs normally but drains slowly points to a clog in the P-trap or the drain line downstream of the unit, not a disposal failure. Before recommending any hardware repair, Scott checks the drain line first. If the clog is past the trap and deeper in the line, that's a job for our drain cleaning service. Replacing a working disposal because of a clogged line is an expensive mistake worth avoiding.

Related

Next step

Tell us about the job

Your name, your number and what needs doing. A person from Right Way Plumbing gets back to you.

Rather talk now?(801) 821-3149

No obligation · Responds within 1 business day

By submitting this form you agree that we may contact you about your request and share your name and email address with partner companies for email marketing. We never share your mobile number or text message consent with third parties or affiliates for marketing or promotional purposes.